The NFL’s Concussion Loophole; Here Come the Digital Playbooks
Today in sports: The iPad comes to the NFL locker room, the problem with the NFL’s concussion policy, and a Red Sox pitcher says he only drank beer in the clubhouse to help the team.
Related: The Hidden Costs of Spain’s Regional Bullfighting Ban
- The Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Baltimore Ravens have both started giving players iPads with the team’s playbook as a preloaded application. It’s a more convenient than having to lug a 700-page playbook back and forth from meeting rooms, and also allows players to watch game tape on tablets. (Right now, the standard is for the team’s video department to burn each player a DVD for takehome study.) In typical NFL fashion, the teams also like the fact they can guard their secrets more closely. “If an incorrect password is entered three times, the app destroys the data on the computer” and Tampa’s front office “has access to the data on its iPads and can remotely destroy information on a device” when a player gets cut. Both teams developed their own playbook applications for the iPad in-house. Both clubs designed the application to “automatically update as coaches adjust strategies throughout the season” and plays are added or removed from the gameplan. The iPads also serve as a datebook for players, automatically alerting them to changes in the practice schedule and what they need to be eating on a given day. The next logical step is for coaches to start using tablets rather than their laminated play-calling sheets that look like giant menus. Currently the league doesn’t allow “any type of computer” on the sidelines, but the rule subject to review in the offseason. If It should be noted that the tablets won’t make say, a page from Bill Walsh’s 1985 49ers playbook, read like it’s written in something other than Greek for those of us who don’t speak football. [The New York Times]
- All of the problems with the NFL’s current concussion policy were on display in the third quarter of Sunday’s Eagles-Redskins game, when Eagles quarterback was allowed to reenter the game a few plays after taking a helmet-to-helmet hit from Redskins safety LaRon Landry. A clearly disoriented Vick had to be helped off the turf by his teammates, prompting Fox color commentator Brian Billick to remark that the quarterback was being propped up “like a punch drunk boxer.” Despite his history of concussions and a new league mandate prohibiting any player diagnosed with a concussion from reentering a game, he was back after missing just one offensive possession. He probably said he was fine to reenter the gamebut “players who are concussed are in no position to be making this kind of decision, which is why medical professionals should be making the ‘go or no go’ decision,” writes Sports Illustrated medical columnist Will Carroll. The trouble is, team doctors are employees of the club and telling a coach you’re ruling a star player out is a big ask. That leads to a situation like what happened with Vick, where an obvious head injury was officially classified as a case of the quarterback having something in his eye. The easy answer, argues Carroll, is to put an independent doctor on every sideline and have him make the call about whether a player can return. [Sports Illustrated]